Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie Made from Scratch by New Market BBQ

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

(3 customer reviews)

$13.95 Excluding Tax

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie – made from scratch scrumptious custard is one of our most popular pies! If you love Peanut Butter, YOU MUST TRY THIS PIE!  

There is a STORY behind this Peanut Butter Pie and how it landed on our menu – Check out THIS BLOG POST for details – in the meantime, be sure to come try a slice and then order a Whole Pie for your family to enjoy! You won't regret it!

There are no nuts included in this recipe – what you see is Peanut Butter Crumbles that we make and put on top of the meringue and beneath the pudding in the pie shell. It's AMAZINGLY GOOD!

10″ Whole Pie serves approximately 8-10.

Description

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie – This scrumptious custard pudding based pie is one of our most popular pies! If you love Peanut Butter, YOU MUST TRY THIS PIE!  

There is a STORY behind this Pie and how it landed on our menu – Check out THIS BLOG POST for details – in the meantime, be sure to come try a slice and then order a Whole Pie for your family to enjoy! You won't regret it!

There are no nuts included in this recipe – what you see is Peanut Butter Crumbles that we make and put on top of the meringue and beneath the pudding in the pie shell. It's AMAZINGLY GOOD!

We prepare all of our desserts using the freshest ingredients right here in our kitchen at New Market BBQ. We choose to make everything from scratch ourselves! We'd love to make one for your special occasion!

10″ Whole Pie serves approximately 8-10.

3 reviews for Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

  1. Lisa Wilcox (verified owner)

    We love New Market BBQ. We have been eating here for years. For Mother’s Day weekend, we picked up a couple of pies (lemon and peanut butter) for a cookout. They were delicious, and everyone absolutely loved them. This may be a new tradition for holidays.

    Was this review helpful to you?
  2. Lisa Wilcox (verified owner)

    The pies were delicious as usual. We love them!

    Was this review helpful to you?
  3. Charles D. (verified owner)

    everything was delish as always!!

    Was this review helpful to you?
Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *