BEST Pina Colada Cake EVER! - New Market BBQ North AL's BEST Weekend BBQ Destination
New Market BBQ North AL's BEST Weekend BBQ Destination
Help us Spread the Word

BEST Pina Colada Cake EVER!

Please help us spread the word about these wonderful recipes and to help you find it later by clicking on the Social Share buttons above. Thanks!

Pina Colada Cake all sliced up and ready to enjoy!

This is one of our weekly cake specials that we offer here at New Market BBQ!


We participate annually in an event put on by the Hospitality Association that we are a member of called the Taste of Huntsville. Every year they have a “theme” and this year it was Margaritaville. I went on the hunt to find a great recipe for a Pina Colada Cake and couldn't really find ONE that I liked, so I combined about 3 different recipes to make up the one we now serve here at our restaurant, and our customers just LOVE this cake! Hope you enjoy it as much as our customers do!!

Just a quick side note, if you want us to make you one of these beauties, be sure to give us atleast a week's notice to be sure we have all necessary supplies on hand to make it for you.

Thanks so much for checking out our website and recipes! ENJOY!!

We look forward to serving you and your family real soon!

Be sure to join our tribe on Facebook and help us grow our small mom and pop business!

With kindest regards and appreciation for your support, Libby Webb

BEST Pina Colada Cake EVER!

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 30 minutes

Total Time: 45 minutes

Yield: 15-20

BEST Pina Colada Cake EVER!

This cake is EXTRA moist and full of wonderful flavor from the pineapple, to the coconut milk, and then the awesome coconut frosting! We hope you enjoy it!

Recipe Ingredients:

  • 1 box yellow cake mix
  • 1 box vanilla pudding
  • 4 eggs
  • 1/2 can Coco Lopez 15 oz
  • 1/3 Cup Oil
  • 1 can drained crushed pineapple, reserve liquid, 22 oz
  • 1 can sweetened condensed milk
  • 1/2 can Coco Lopez 15 oz
  • 1 Cup reserved Pineapple Juice
  • Frosting
  • 1 Cup Sugar
  • 1 Large Tubs Whipped Topping
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • 1 Large bag shredded coconut—save some for garnishing the top

How to Prepare:

  1. Combine sugar, sour cream, whipped topping, and coconut.
  2. Blend well and chill while you prepare the cake.
  3. Preheat Oven to 325
  4. Prepare cake by Dry beating cake mix & pudding until lump free
  5. Add eggs, oil and 1/2 can of Coconut Milk
  6. Mix until well blended, approximately 2 minutes being sure to stir from the bottom.
  7. Mix in 1 can of drained crushed pineapple.
  8. Bake in a 9x13 inch pan for approx. 25-30 minutes depending on your oven. We use convection.
  9. Let cake rest in pan for about 10 min.
  10. Mix Sweet Condensed Milk, 1/2 Can of Coconut Milk, and 1 cup Pineapple Juice together
  11. Poke holes in cake with end of butter knife or other utensil that isn't too small or too large
  12. Pour mixture over cake ensuring to get into the holes to soak into the cake.
  13. Cool cake completely.
  14. Add Frosting and cover well.
  15. I like to garnish with toasted Coconut.


We use a gas convection oven here in our restaurant, so our temp and cook times are based on that, which for most home cooks, you may need to bump up the cook temp and adjust the time a little.

Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by Yummly Rich Recipes

About the Author Libby Webb

Owner / Operator of New Market BBQ since 2008

Merry Christmas and Welcome to the NEW Website! | New Market BBQ Best Old School Pit Smoked BBQ found in the New Market and Huntsville AL area. says December 15, 2013

[…] We hope you like it and find it easier to navigate and can find our information  more easily.  It is a work in progress, so bare with us please as we make adjustments and learn how to make the most of our new platform.  We are looking forward to providing you with all kinds of great content, including Recipes, so stay tuned and THANK YOU for your continued business and support! (CHECKOUT our FIRST Recipe that we’ve released by special request from one of our wonderful customers – Pina’ Colada Cake! […]

Alexandria Mitchell says December 16, 2013

This is a good one

New Market BBQ says December 17, 2013

Glad you like it Alexandria!

Comments are closed