We pride ourselves here at New Market BBQ on making most everything we sell from scratch, and that includes ALL of our delicious desserts! Our Coconut Pie custard starts with all the basics of a made from scratch pudding including flour, eggs, milk and so on but did you know that using a Quality Vanilla Extract can dramatically change the flavor of your desserts? Give it a try! We love the Watkins brand flavorings here at New Market BBQ. We also use an amazing quality Meringue Stabilizer, so rest assured your Whole Pie will hold up nicely in your fridge for several days, that is IF it lasts that long! LOL!!